Backlink AnalysisBacklink Audit Guide

How to Do a Backlink Analysis (Plus an Audit Checklist)

A step-by-step backlink analysis: the numbers worth trusting, a ten-point audit checklist, how to handle toxic links, and how to turn a competitor's links into your to-do list.

Woman reviewing analytics charts on a laptop at a bright home office desk
On this page

A site owner opens a backlink tool, sees "14,000 backlinks" and feels like they're winning. Then they can't work out why they're still stuck on page three. Both things are true at once. The number is real, and it tells them almost nothing: those 14,000 links come from maybe 40 domains, and half of those are scraper sites copying their content.

A backlink analysis turns that big, useless number into lists you can act on: the good links worth protecting, the few dragging you down, and the sites linking to your competitors that should be linking to you. Here's how to do one step by step, with the audit checklist worth running every month.

At a glance

  • A seven-step analysis you can repeat every month
  • A ten-point backlink audit checklist
  • How to tell a toxic link from one that is merely ugly
  • How a competitor's links become your to-do list
  • Updated November 2026
Start here

What a backlink analysis actually tells you

Strip away the jargon and you're answering one question: is my link profile helping me, hurting me, or just sitting there? A proper analysis sorts every link into one of three piles.

The three verdicts of a backlink analysis. Keep and build on: strong, relevant links such as a trade blog citing your guide, usually most of your profile. Watch or remove: links that look built, such as a link farm or exact-match anchors from junk sites, usually a small handful. Go and get: sites that link to your competitors but not to you, which become your link-building brief. Keep and build onWatch or removeGo and get Strong, relevant linksLinks that look builtYour competitors' links Trade blog citing your guide A partner's resource page Link farm, 500 outbound links Exact-match anchor, junk site Roundup listing two rivals A directory your niche uses Most of your profile A small handful Your link-building brief
Every link lands in one of three piles. The third pile is the one most audits forget.

That third pile is why analysis isn't only defensive spring cleaning. Done well, it's the most reliable link-building brief you'll ever get, because it's built entirely from links that already exist.

The numbers

Which numbers matter, and which ones mislead

Every tool floods you with metrics. Here's how much weight each one deserves.

MetricWhat it tells youTrust it
Referring domainsHow many separate sites link to you. The best single measure of a profile's sizeA lot
Anchor text mixWhether your links look earned or builtA lot
Link velocityHow fast links arrive and disappear. Spikes and drops both mean somethingA lot
Authority score (DR, DA, Trust Flow)A tool's own 0 to 100 estimate of link strength. None of them comes from GoogleIn one tool
Dofollow and nofollow splitWhether the profile looks natural. 100% dofollow is a warning signSanity check
Total backlinksEvery individual link, sitewide footers includedBarely

If referring domains versus total backlinks is new to you, our guide on how to check backlinks for free shows why the smaller number is the one to watch.

Anchor text deserves a closer look, because it's usually the first thing worth fixing. Natural profiles are dominated by brand names, bare URLs and plain phrases like "this guide". When the exact keyword you want to rank for starts crowding those out, the pattern looks built.

Two example anchor text mixes. A natural-looking profile: 40% branded, 25% naked URL, 20% generic, 10% partial match and 5% exact match. An over-optimized profile: 15% branded, 10% naked URL, 10% generic, 20% partial match and 45% exact match. Natural-looking Example profile Over-optimized Exact match takes over 40%25%20%10% 15%10%10%20%45% exact match BrandedLinkRocket Naked URLlinkrocket.ai Genericthis guide Partial matchtools for backlinks Exact matchbacklink checker
Illustrative mixes. There is no official safe percentage. The warning sign is exact-match anchors crowding out your brand.

Our guide to anchor text optimization goes deeper on what a healthy mix looks like and how to rebalance one that isn't.

The routine

How to do a backlink analysis in seven steps

Run this once a month in any capable tool. The first pass is the slowest. After that, you're mostly reading what changed.

  1. 1
    Export the full listEvery referring domain with its authority score, anchor text, first-seen date and dofollow or nofollow status. A sample won't do here.
  2. 2
    Read the overall shapeAre referring domains growing, flat or shrinking? Is the anchor mix mostly your brand? Do links point at your homepage or spread across your pages?
  3. 3
    Sort by authority and read both endsThe top of the list is what to protect and copy. The bottom is where problems hide.
  4. 4
    Check relevanceA link from a small site in your niche can beat a big one from an unrelated site. Note which links fit your topic and which don't.
  5. 5
    Flag the risky linksMark link farms, unrelated foreign-language sites and pages stuffed with outbound links. Flag them, but don't disavow on reflex. More on that below.
  6. 6
    Match link changes to rankingsLay the links you won and lost over your ranking history. A ranking dip that lines up with a lost link usually explains itself.
  7. 7
    Pull one competitor's link gapList the sites that link to a competitor who outranks you but not to you. That's next month's outreach list.

Save the export each time. The second month is where analysis starts paying off, because you can see what actually changed instead of staring at a single snapshot.

LinkRocket backlink report for chatgpt.com with Export CSV, Share Report and Save Analysis buttons above the report tabs and the Homepage Distribution AnalysisExport all
Step 1 in LinkRocket: every backlink report exports to CSV. The Top Pages tab's Homepage Distribution Analysis answers the "homepage or inner pages?" question in step 2.

In LinkRocket, the History tab covers step 6: it charts backlinks and referring domains over 90 days on the Pro plan and over one year on Business and Agency, so you can see links won and lost next to the dates your rankings moved.

Checklist

The backlink audit checklist

The seven steps are the routine. This is what you're looking for while you run it. Ten checks, grouped by what they protect.

Backlink audit checklist with ten checks. Growth: referring domains up or down, lost links from your top 20 domains, new links you didn't build. Shape: share of exact-match anchors, homepage versus inner-page links. Risk: unrelated or foreign-language sites, sitewide footer and sidebar links, domains with a high spam score. Wins: dead pages that still have links, and a refreshed competitor gap. Backlink audit checklist Run it monthly Referring domains up or down?Growth Lost links from your top 20 domainsGrowth New links you didn't buildGrowth Share of exact-match anchorsShape Homepage vs inner-page linksShape Unrelated or foreign-language sitesRisk Sitewide footer and sidebar linksRisk Domains with a high spam scoreRisk Dead pages that still have linksWin Competitor gap, refreshedWin
Ten checks for a monthly backlink audit. Growth and Risk catch problems; the two Wins are the fastest links you'll ever gain.

Most of these are self-explanatory once you've run the seven steps. Three are worth a sentence each.

New links you didn't build. Most are good news: someone found your work and cited it. Thank them, and see what else they cover. Now and then it's a burst of spam pointed at you, which is worth knowing about even if you end up doing nothing.

Homepage versus inner-page links. If nearly all your links point at the homepage, your guides and product pages are ranking on very little. That's a sign to build links to the pages you actually want found.

Dead pages that still have links. This is the quickest win in SEO. Find pages that return a 404 but still have backlinks, then 301-redirect each one to the closest live page. You keep the value of links you already earned, without sending a single email.

Pro tip

Lost a link from one of your top 20 domains? Check the page first. Often the article was updated or moved and the link fell out by accident. A short, friendly email gets a surprising number of them back.

Risk

Every profile collects junk. Scrapers copy your pages, directories list you without asking, and spam sites link to anything that ranks. Almost none of it matters. Google says its systems can work out which links to trust without help in most cases, and that most sites will never need its disavow tool.

So the skill isn't finding ugly links. It's telling the harmless ugly ones from the few that can genuinely hurt you. A link deserves a closer look when it comes from:

  • a site that exists to link out, with hundreds of unrelated outbound links on each page
  • a network of near-identical sites that all link to the same handful of domains
  • an unrelated site in another language, especially with an exact-match keyword as the anchor
  • a sitewide footer or sidebar link you didn't ask for, repeated across thousands of pages
  • a sudden burst of links you can't explain

In LinkRocket, every link in a report carries a Risk Score of low, medium or high, and each domain shows a spam score. Sort the Backlinks tab by Risk Score and review the links marked high first. A domain spam score under 10% is healthy; above 30%, look at the links driving it.

What to do with a risky-looking link. Ask two questions: did you build, buy or swap this link, and is there a manual action in Search Console? If neither, leave it alone, because Google's systems ignore most spammy links. If you built or bought it, ask the site to remove it and disavow the links you can't get removed. If there's a manual action, remove or disavow the links, then file a reconsideration request. A link looks risky High Risk Score Ask two questions 1 Did you build, buy orswap this link? 2 Is there a manual actionin Search Console? IF NEITHER Leave it alone Google already ignores most spammy links IF YOU BUILT OR BOUGHT IT Ask the site to remove it Disavow the links you can't get removed IF THERE'S A MANUAL ACTION Clean up, then ask for review Remove or disavow, then request a review
Most risky-looking links land in the green box. The disavow file is for the other two.
Don't disavow on a score alone

A risk score tells you where to look, not what to do. Disavowing a link that was quietly helping you costs rankings, and you won't get a warning. Open the page, judge it yourself, and save the disavow file for links you built or bought, or for a manual action.

Offense

Turn a competitor's links into your to-do list

Step 7 is where analysis stops being housekeeping. Pick one competitor that outranks you for a search you want, list every site that links to them, and strike out the ones that already link to you. What's left is a list of sites that cover your topic and have said yes to someone like you.

Look for patterns. If three competitors all have links from the same industry roundup, that roundup is your first email. Our competitor backlink analysis guide covers how to pick competitors and qualify each prospect.

Try it

Find your link gaps with Competitor Analysis

Compare your site with up to 10 competitors and get the list of sites that link to them but not to you.

See Competitor Analysis
LinkRocket Competitor Analysis comparing two domains, with the Comparison, Market Share, Trends and History tabs
Tools

Choosing a backlink analysis tool without overpaying

The right tool has an index big enough to find your links, data fresh enough to catch changes, and a price you'll still be happy paying in six months. Here's the honest lay of the land.

ToolBest forThe catch
LinkRocketAnalysis plus the tools to act on it, from link gaps to the Backlink Exchange and Publisher MarketplaceIts index isn't as deep as Ahrefs'
AhrefsThe deepest, freshest link data aroundPriced for heavy users and agencies
SemrushOne platform for everything, if you already pay for itExpensive as a backlink-only purchase
Moz ProApproachable reports, and Link Intersect for gapsA smaller index, so it misses some links
MajesticLink quality through Trust Flow and Citation FlowA dated interface, and more specialized

If you live in backlink data all day and budget isn't a concern, Ahrefs is still the one to beat. That isn't controversial. But it describes few of the people reading this. The big suites are built and priced for agencies, and a site owner checking their profile twice a month ends up paying for dozens of features they never open.

That gap is why LinkRocket exists. Each report grades your profile from A to F, scores every link from 0 to 100 for value and low to high for risk, and shows DR, DA, Trust Flow and Citation Flow side by side. Next to it sit the tools to act on what you find, so measuring links and building them don't need two subscriptions.

Try it

Run your backlink audit in LinkRocket

A health grade, a risk score on every link, CSV export and history over time. The Free plan includes 2 reports a month with up to 100 backlinks each.

See Backlink Analysis
Avoid these

Five ways people get backlink analysis wrong

Most bad analysis comes down to the same handful of habits.

  • Worshipping the total count. Big number, small meaning. Referring domains and quality are what move rankings.
  • Comparing scores across tools. A DR and a DA aren't the same currency. Pick one tool and stay in it.
  • Disavowing everything ugly. Google already ignores most junk links. Overusing the disavow file can strip out links that were quietly helping.
  • Judging by authority alone. A relevant link from a smaller site in your niche often beats a big link from an unrelated one.
  • Running it once. Profiles shift every month. Analysis is a habit, not an event.
Wrapping up

The short version

Backlink analysis gets simple once you tune out the noise. Count referring domains, not links. Judge quality and relevance, not size. Watch how the profile moves month to month, leave harmless junk alone, and treat the gap between you and your competitors as a to-do list rather than a scoreboard.

Do that every month and it compounds. You stop guessing which links matter, you catch problems before they dent your rankings, and every audit hands you the next batch of links worth chasing.

Frequently asked questions

What is a backlink analysis?

A backlink analysis reviews the links pointing to a website to judge their quality, relevance and risk. It shows which links help your rankings, which do nothing, which might hurt you, and which sites link to your competitors but not to you. Most sites benefit from running one every month.

How do I do a backlink audit?

Export every referring domain with its authority score, anchor text and first-seen date. Check whether referring domains are growing, review the anchor mix, flag risky links, redirect dead pages that still have links, and compare your profile with a competitor's. Save the export so next month you can see what changed.

How do I find toxic backlinks?

Look for links from sites that exist only to link out, networks of near-identical sites, unrelated foreign-language sites using exact-match anchors, and sitewide links you never asked for. In LinkRocket, sort the Backlinks tab by Risk Score and review the links marked high first, then check each domain's spam score.

Should I disavow toxic backlinks?

Usually not. Google says most sites never need the disavow tool, because its systems already ignore most spammy links. Disavow links you built or paid for that break Google's spam policies, or links behind a manual action in Search Console. Disavowing good links by mistake can cost you rankings.

How often should I analyze my backlinks?

Monthly suits most sites. Regular checks catch lost links and spam bursts early, show whether your link building is working, and let you line up ranking changes with the links you won and lost. During an active campaign, or after a sudden ranking drop, check more often.

Which backlink analysis tool is best?

Ahrefs has the deepest data, Semrush suits teams that want one platform for everything, and Moz and Majestic each have distinctive strengths. LinkRocket pairs a full backlink analysis with the tools to act on it, such as Competitor Analysis and the Backlink Exchange. It comes down to budget and whether you also need to build links.

Grade your link profile from A to F, see the risk on every link and export the full list. Start on the Free plan.

Analyze your backlinks

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply